What does a reviewed audit add?
A reviewed website audit answers a broader question. It asks whether the service is understandable, whether the evidence supports the claims, whether important terms are consistent, whether the next action makes sense and which technical problems deserve attention first.
A machine-readable warning is still useful evidence. It is not always the whole diagnosis.
When should you use each?
Use an automated checker when the question is narrow and technical. Use a reviewed audit when several signals need to be interpreted together and turned into tasks.